Newsletters
News & Information for Technology Purchasers NewsFactor Sites:       NewsFactor.com     Enterprise Security Today     CRM Daily     Business Report     Sci-Tech Today  
   
This ad will display for the next 20 seconds. Click for more information, or
Home Enterprise I.T. Cloud Computing Applications Hardware More Topics...
Apple/Mac
DDoS Protection Powered By Verisign
Average Rating:
Rate this article:  
Apple Sued for Disparity in MacBook Pro Displays

Apple Sued for Disparity in MacBook Pro Displays
By Adam Dickter

Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linkedin Share on Google Plus

Not all MacBook Pro Retina displays are created equal and that could mean trouble for Apple. "The performance disparity between the LG version and the Samsung version is particularly troubling given that Apple represents the MacBook Pro with retina display as a single, unitary product, described as the highest quality notebook display."
 


All MacBook Pro computers may look the same on the outside, but components cause disparity in the quality of displays, a California man claims in a class-action suit filed this week.

The suit alleges that panels made by LG cause "ghosting" or burn-in for the Retina display, while Samsung panels used in the same machines do not.

Ghosts in the Machine

Apple's Retina is a liquid crystal display that Apple claims is so sharp that an actual human retina cannot detect the pixels without looking extremely closely. Since introducing Retina in the iPhone 4 in 2011, Apple has now added it to the iPhone 4S, the fourth-generation iPod Touch, the third- and fourth-generation iPad, and iPhone 5, as well as the MacBook Pro 15-inch and MacBook Pro 13-inch.

It's on the latter devices, introduced last June, that some consumers complained of the ghosting or burn-in of static screen imagery. Apple addressed the issue on Feb. 15 on its support blog, telling the public that "image persistence" was due to in-plane switching, which allows an enhanced viewing experience with 178-degree viewing angles in all directions. The IPS screens allowed images such as login windows that are left on screen for too long to leave a "faint remnant" even after a new image replaces it.

Apple's advice was to "turn off the display when it is not in use" with the display sleep feature or use a screen saver, both options available on Mac OS X with adjustment controls.

Commenters on that blog took exception to the idea that image retention is a normal occurrence.

"I've had several iMacs with IPS panels and not one of them has ever exhibited a bit of IR or 'ghosting,' " wrote Barry Fisher.

"Ghosting is apparently occurring on several of the new [MacBook Pro] Retina screens using LG panels."

That's the basis for the suit filed by Beau Hodges, who says customers have no way of knowing if they're getting a MacBook with Samsung or LG panels. Apple, meanwhile, markets both as equal in quality.

Nuisance Suit or Valid Complaint?

The suit was filed Wednesday in San Francisco, in the U.S. District Court for Northern California -- home of countless technology-related legal battles because it has jurisdiction over Silicon Valley -- before Judge Laurel Keeler.

"The performance disparity between the LG version and the Samsung version is particularly troubling given that Apple represents the MacBook Pro with retina display as a single, unitary product, described as the highest quality notebook display on the market," says the lawsuit in a passage widely quoted in the tech media on Friday.

Apple did not respond to our request for comment sent on Friday afternoon to two spokespeople in time for publication.

We also asked Charles King, principal analyst at Pund-IT, for his thoughts on the case. King suggests that such cases usually don't stand much of a chance against Apple's legal team and amount to little more than nuisance suits.

"For a company like Apple, serious and self-funded competitors like Samsung represent a greater threat" in the legal arena, King said. "While it isn't impossible for a lone horseman tilting against a very large windmill to inflict some minor damage, the likelihood of major injury is typically small."

That being said, it will be interesting to see if lone horseman Beau Hodges will indeed have an impact with the lawsuit filed, and whether Apple might somehow compensate MacBook owners who ended up with the allegedly lower quality displays.
 

Tell Us What You Think
Comment:

Name:

AppleNotSoGreat:

Posted: 2013-05-09 @ 6:05pm PT
Apple has too many times not manned up when a device clearly has a problem. To me, on many occasions, they should have issued a recall, and fixed the problem. Instead, Apple pretends the problem does not exist, continues to sell millions of devices, and oftentimes even the follow-up devices have issues. I have had several faulty Apple products. I do not trust Apple to stand behind their products, because Apple decides what it thinks is a flaw. Even when thousands of consumers are complaining about the exact same flaw, Apple cannot be bothered. So I, for one, am glad to see this guy take Apple to court, Apple SHOULD be taken to task for such matters. I don't care how big a legal team they have; they shouldn't just be allowed to steamroller over the little guy. Especially all of us who pay a LOT of money for these overpriced products.

john:

Posted: 2013-03-18 @ 1:31am PT
It points to the sad state of the "justice system". Whoever has the most money wins. Sounds like bull to me.

Carney1:

Posted: 2013-03-16 @ 9:34am PT
At the very least, I think that owners of the bad displays should be entitled to a rebate. C'mon Apple... do the right thing.



Salesforce.com is the market and technology leader in Software-as-a-Service. Its award-winning CRM solution helps 82,400 customers worldwide manage and share business information over the Internet. Experience CRM success. Click here for a FREE 30-day trial.


 Apple/Mac
1.   Apple Stock Soars Ahead of IPhone 6
2.   Popular Mailbox App Comes to Mac
3.   Apple Opens China iCloud Data Center
4.   Android Crushing Smartphone Rivals
5.   Apple Bans Toxic Factory Chemicals


advertisement
New App To Manage Time Better
Helping to organize your busy life.
Average Rating:
Apple Stock Soars Ahead of IPhone 6
New products generating lots of buzz.
Average Rating:
Popular Mailbox App Comes to Mac
Takes to-do list approach to the inbox.
Average Rating:


advertisement


 Random Bytes
Apple Opens China iCloud Data Center Popular Mailbox App Comes to Mac
New Apple iPad Models on the Way Apple Stock Soars Ahead of IPhone 6
Product Information and Resources for Technology You Can Use To Boost Your Business

Network Security Spotlight
Aruba Networks Handles Black Hat with Aplomb
It's not an easy job. Aruba Networks' task throughout the Black Hat USA conference in Las Vegas this month was to ensure thousands of attendees could connect without malicious attacks.
 
Chinese Hackers Nab Info on Millions of U.S. Patients
A group of Chinese hackers has stolen the personal information, including names and Social Security numbers, of about 4.5 million patients at hospitals operated by Community Health Systems.
 
Premier FBI Cybersquad in U.S. To Add Agents
After helping prosecutors charge Chinese army officials with stealing trade secrets from major companies and by snaring a Russian-led hacking ring, the premier FBI cyber-squad is getting a boost.
 

Enterprise Hardware Spotlight
Aruba Networks Handles Black Hat with Aplomb
It's not an easy job. Aruba Networks' task throughout the Black Hat USA conference in Las Vegas this month was to ensure thousands of attendees could connect without malicious attacks.
 
Compression, Deduplication Come to Violin Concerto 2200
Violin Memory has announced that data deduplication and compression capabilities are now available on its Concerto 2200 solution. Typically, users will experience deduplication rates between 6:1 and 10:1.
 
Cisco Axes 6,000 Employees in Restructuring Plan
Faced with declining profits, Cisco is laying off up to 6,000 employees in the months ahead -- a whopping 8 percent of its global workforce. That's in addition to the 4,000 jobs Cisco cut last year.
 

Mobile Technology Spotlight
Apple Stock Soars Ahead of iPhone 6 Launch
The imminent release of the iPhone 6 -- and maybe even an iWatch -- has sent Apple's stock soaring to new heights. Considering what else the firm could have up its sleeve -- the stratosphere may be the limit.
 
HTC Debuts Windows Phone Version of One M8 Smartphone
HTC is bringing the Windows Phone mobile OS to its flagship One M8 device -- the first time any mainstream flagship smartphone has been offered with a choice of operating systems.
 
Verizon Earns Top Rating in Mobile Network Comparison
A new report says Verizon Wireless was the top-performing U.S. cellphone service provider in the first half of 2014, on a nationwide and state-by-state basis, as well as in metro areas.
 

Navigation
NewsFactor Network
Home/Top News | Enterprise I.T. | Cloud Computing | Applications | Hardware | Mobile Tech | Big Data | Communications
World Wide Web | Network Security | Data Storage | CRM Systems | Microsoft/Windows | Apple/Mac | Linux/Open Source | Personal Tech
Press Releases
NewsFactor Network Enterprise I.T. Sites
NewsFactor Technology News | Enterprise Security Today | CRM Daily

NewsFactor Business and Innovation Sites
Sci-Tech Today | NewsFactor Business Report

NewsFactor Services
FreeNewsFeed | Free Newsletters

About NewsFactor Network | How To Contact Us | Article Reprints | Careers @ NewsFactor | Services for PR Pros | Top Tech Wire | How To Advertise

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
© Copyright 2000-2014 NewsFactor Network. All rights reserved. Article rating technology by Blogowogo. Member of Accuserve Ad Network.