Notching up its efforts to generate revenue from its intellectual property,
the SCO Group is planning to send invoices to commercial Linux users, possibly by the
end of September. The invoices will be sent out to "several thousand
companies," SCO spokesperson Blake Stowell told NewsFactor.
SCO claims that Linux contains code from the Unix OS, to which SCO owns the
copyright. This claim is at the center of SCO's US$3 billion lawsuit
against IBM, which alleges that Big Blue misappropriated SCO's Unix source code and
incorporated it into Linux.
IBM has denied that charge and has filed a countersuit against SCO.
Because SCO's Linux invoices will be based on a disputed claim, analysts
question the technique's effectiveness. The invoices "are an interesting
gambit," Yankee analyst Laura DiDio told NewsFactor. Yet the company "cannot
enforce" its payment demand, because its legal claim is still pending, she
noted.
Licensing Linux
In July, SCO announced that it expected enterprise Linux users to buy a Unix
operating license. The license's proposed price was $699 for a single-processor server. The company threatened legal action against Linux users
who did not comply with its licensing demands.
In an effort to collect the licensing fees, SCO will invoice "known companies that are
using Linux and who have been very public about their use of Linux," Stowell
said.
The amount of the invoice "depends on the server installation" a given
company has, he said, adding that the invoice amount will be based on the
$699 per processor figure. Larger users will get a slight discount, he explained.
SCO's invoicing strategy "could backfire," DiDio said. "The danger for SCO
is that they alienate those companies who might have been considering paying
a licensing fee. This might be too pushy."
Dell: No Protection For Linux Clients
In a related development, computer-maker Dell -- a major proponent of
Linux and, therefore, a likely recipient of a SCO invoice -- has announced
it will not indemnify its customers from possible legal ramifications
arising from Linux use.
Some of Dell's larger Linux customer reportedly had asked the computer maker
for legal protection.
But leading Linux vendor IBM has said such indemnification is not necessary.
"The terms of the GPL make it clear that there are no warranties or
indemnities with Linux, and our customers understand that," IBM spokesperson
Trink Guarino told NewsFactor.
SCO Is Fined
SCO has been fined by a German court for failing to properly comply with a ruling that ordered the company to desist from making ownership claims of the Linux kernel in Germany.
In May, German Linux organization LinuxTag filed suit against SCO after the
company sent letters to 1,500 corporations worldwide warning of potential
legal problems arising from using Linux. LinuxTag obtained a restraining
order that ruled SCO must retract its Linux claims or make its evidence
public. In response, SCO took down its German site.
Now, LinuxTag has filed another legal complaint against SCO, claiming that
SCO showed a link to the Linux letter to its business partners. The judge
ruled in LinuxTag's favor, fining SCO 10,000 euros, or about $10,000
dollars. SCO is appealing the ruling.
|