The U.S. National Security Agency (NSA), the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
and city officials in Tampa, Florida are among the winner's of this year's "Big Brother"
awards for their Internet-related gaffes.
The online privacy group Privacy International handed out the dubious
achievement awards on Wednesday during its 3rd annual "Computers, Privacy
and Freedom" conference in Cambridge, Massachusetts, officials said.
The NSA took top honors for
the "Lifetime Menace Award." Despite the NSA's attempts to make their services
more "user-friendly," Privacy International's David Banisar told news
sources, the agency's half-century of spying was more than enough to win
the award.
Carnivore Most Heinous
The FBI's Carnivore Internet project took the award for "Most Heinous
Project," Banisar said.
Carnivore is the FBI's e-mail surveillance system designed to weed through
innocuous e-mails and search out the meaty, eyebrow-raising messages. The
Electronic Privacy Information Center
(EPIC), an online advocacy group, won a court order last summer to have
the FBI disclose the workings of the program.
After making upgrades to the system, the FBI changed Carnivore's name to the less aggressive and perhaps more official-sounding "DCS1000."
Tampa Face-Mappers
City officials in Tampa, Florida, meanwhile, took the award for the "Worst Government
Official/Agency," for its notorious decision to videotape the faces of fans
attending this year's Super Bowl and match them against a criminal
recognition program.
Privacy International's "Greatest Corporate Invader Award," went to ChoicePoint, a
company that sold U.S. Department of Transportation data , and also supplied lists of
Texas-based felons to the state of Florida so officials there
could purge voting rolls for the 2000 Presidential Election.
Also-Rans
Other contenders for the "Lifetime Menace" award included IBM, for its
Capitol Hill lobbying against privacy laws, and the Direct Marketing
Association for "making sure that junk mail is officially delivered."
Nortel Networks and VeriSign's Network Solutions were runners-up for the
"Greatest Corporate Invader Award." Network Solutions received special
recognition for selling its WHOIS database to direct marketers, the privacy group
said.
The U.S. Department of Justice took honors for the Cybercrime.gov project, while
three Pennsylvania school districts were recognized for a school initiative that
links a student biometrics program to school lunch programs.
And though it's now in the history books, the Clinton
Administration's medical privacy regulations were targeted for allowing the
sale of supposedly confidential patient data.
This year's "winners" were determined by a panel of judges that included
Banisar, JunkBusters president Jason Catlett, Privacy Journal editor Bob
Smith, Wayne Madsen of EPIC, and Nadine
Strossen, president of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU).
|