News & Information for Technology Purchasers NewsFactor Sites:     Enterprise Security Today     CRM Daily     Business Report     Sci-Tech Today  
Home Enterprise I.T. Cloud Computing Applications Hardware More Topics...
Eliminate costly downtime!
Find out how with Free White Paper
& enter to win a Samsung Galaxy Note
Real-time info services with Neustar
Average Rating:
Rate this article:  
Apple v. Samsung: Jury Begins Deliberations
Apple v. Samsung: Jury Begins Deliberations

By Howard Mintz
April 30, 2014 9:36AM

    Bookmark and Share
Lawyers for feuding tech titans Apple and Samsung have rested their case, leaving the question of patent rights in the hands of a jury. Apple cast Samsung as a desperate copier of iPhone technology, while Samsung portrayed Apple as a waning force trying to sway a hometown jury to hand out a big payday to squelch competition.

After more than four weeks of trial hostility between Apple and Samsung, the multibillion-dollar question of patent rights in the smartphone wars is officially in the hands of an eight-member Silicon Valley jury.

Lawyers for the feuding tech titans spent four hours Tuesday giving that federal court jury competing visions of what unfolded during the trial -- Apple keeping to its script of casting Samsung as a desperate copier of iPhone technology, and Samsung portraying Apple as a waning force trying to sway a hometown jury to hand out a big payday to squelch competition.

The jury will return to federal court Wednesday to resume deliberations, the latest jury handed the task of deciding a legal showdown between Apple and Samsung.

Harold McElhinny, Apple's lead attorney, urged the jury to side with Apple and order Samsung to pay as much as $2.2 billion in damages for violating the patents on five iPhone and iPad software features, such as slide-to-unlock and auto-word correct. Samsung, Apple estimates, has sold 37 million of the nine smartphone models and one tablet alleged to have copied those patents.

"Apple cannot simply walk away from its inventions," McElhinny told the jury. "And so, here we are, 37 million acts of infringement later, and we're counting on you for justice. The size of this illegal (conduct) is beyond comprehension."

Samsung lawyers, however, again stressed that Apple's allegations center on Google's Android technology, which ran the Samsung devices, and that Apple is carrying out late CEO Steve Jobs' 2010 internal pledge to conduct a "holy war" on the Mountain View search giant.

John Quinn, Samsung's lead lawyer, told jurors Apple would rather target a foreign competitor such as South Korea-based Samsung than pick a fight with another local valley power, Google.

"This suit was a long shot," an animated Quinn said. "It's in their backyard. They certainly weren't going to take on the local company, Google in Mountain View, and they didn't."

Samsung has argued that even if the jury sides with Apple, the iPhone maker inflated its damages request and it should not receive more than $38 million. "They'll be dancing in the streets of Cupertino if you give them $100 million," Quinn remarked.

But Apple's lawyers, citing a trove of evidence that Samsung copied iPhone technology to keep pace in the smartphone and tablet market, struck back hard, arguing the trial had nothing to do with Google or Android. Apple stressed throughout the case that Samsung, not Google, decided what technology to include and sell in its products.

"You will not find a single question about Google in your jury form," McElhinny told the jury. "Google is not a defendant in this case."

Dismissing Samsung's $38 million damages estimate, McElhinny told the jury that Samsung would succeed in copying Apple's innovations if the punishment were so light. "That is Samsung's strategy," he said.

The jury deciding the outcome is largely without any tech expertise, other than one juror who once worked for IBM. There are no current valley techies on the panel, unlike the jury in the 2012 first trial between the rivals, which resulted in a nearly $1 billion award against Samsung for an older line of smartphones and tablets.

That first jury's foreman had an engineering background and held patents of his own. That jury took about three days to reach a verdict.

© 2014 San Jose Mercury News (CA) under contract with NewsEdge. All rights reserved.

Tell Us What You Think


APC has an established a reputation for solid products that virtually pay for themselves upon installation. Who has time to spend worrying about system downtime? APC makes it easy for you to focus on business growth instead of business downtime with reliable data center systems and IT solutions. Learn more here.

1.   Mac OS Yosemite Beta 4 Released
2.   Apple Smart Watch Patent Surfaces
3.   iPhone 6: Bad for Apple Tablet Sales?
4.   Longtime Apple Director Steps Down
5.   Business Impact of IBM-Apple Deal

Apple Digital Book Settlement Set
But company still appealing decision.
Average Rating:
Mac OS Yosemite Beta 4 Released
Public preview could be coming soon.
Average Rating:
iPhone 6: Bad for Apple Tablet Sales?
Most likely, it will be a huge hit.
Average Rating:

Product Information and Resources for Technology You Can Use To Boost Your Business

Network Security Spotlight
34 European Banks Hit by Android-Skirting Malware
Criminals have been finding gaping holes in Android-based two-factor authentication systems that banks around the world are using. The result: 34 banks in four European countries have been hit.
New Web Tracking Technologies Defeat Privacy Protections
Recently developed Web tracking tools are able to circumvent even the best privacy defenses, according to a new study by researchers at Princeton and the University of Leuven in Belgium.
Juniper DDoS Solution Aims at High-IQ Networks
In the face of more complex attacks, Juniper Networks is boosting its DDoS Secure solution to help companies mitigate the threats with more effective security intelligence throughout the network fabric.

Enterprise Hardware Spotlight
Contrary to Report, Lenovo's Staying in Small Windows Tablets
Device maker Lenovo has clarified a report that indicated it is getting out of the small Windows tablet business -- as in the ThinkPad 8 and the 8-inch Miix 2. But the firm said it is not exiting that market.
Seagate Unveils Networked Drives for Small Businesses
Seagate is out with five new networked attached storage products aimed at small businesses. The drives are for companies with up to 50 workers, and range in capacity from two to 20 terabytes.
Another Day, Another Internet of Things Consortium Is Born
In the emerging Internet of Things, zillions of devices will be talking to each other. Samsung, Intel and Dell just formed a consortium to ensure each thing can understand what others are saying.

Mobile Technology Spotlight
Apple Patent for Smart Watch Comes to Light
Does a new smart watch patent issued to Apple provide a preview of the expected wearable from the tech giant? Some Apple-watchers are parsing the patent for signs of the coming product.
Will iPhone 6 Cannibalize Apple's Tablet Sales?
Could Apple’s iPhone 6 -- it’s so-called super-size phone due to hit store shelves this fall -- come back to haunt the smartphone maker? Some observers say yes; others say preposterous.
Axed Nokia X Phones Suffered from Lack of Identity
So long, Nokia X, we hardly knew you. The Nokia X phones Microsoft discontinued blend two rival operating systems, but leave out the best of each. As a result, the devices didn't become a runaway hit.

NewsFactor Network
Home/Top News | Enterprise I.T. | Cloud Computing | Applications | Hardware | Mobile Tech | Big Data | Communications
World Wide Web | Network Security | Data Storage | Small Business | Microsoft/Windows | Apple/Mac | Linux/Open Source | Personal Tech
Press Releases
NewsFactor Network Enterprise I.T. Sites
NewsFactor Technology News | Enterprise Security Today | CRM Daily

NewsFactor Business and Innovation Sites
Sci-Tech Today | NewsFactor Business Report

NewsFactor Services
FreeNewsFeed | Free Newsletters

About NewsFactor Network | How To Contact Us | Article Reprints | Careers @ NewsFactor | Services for PR Pros | Top Tech Wire | How To Advertise

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
© Copyright 2000-2014 NewsFactor Network. All rights reserved. Article rating technology by Blogowogo. Member of Accuserve Ad Network.