Newsletters
News & Information for Technology Purchasers NewsFactor Sites:       NewsFactor.com     Enterprise Security Today     CRM Daily     Business Report     Sci-Tech Today  
   
This ad will display for the next 20 seconds. Click for more information, or
Home Enterprise I.T. Cloud Computing Applications Hardware More Topics...
GET RECOGNIZED.
Let an ISACA® certification
elevate your career.

Register today and save
Computing
Tame your scariest paperwork. Find Out How
Average Rating:
Rate this article:  
Microsoft Wins Patent Case Against Motorola
Microsoft Wins Patent Case Against Motorola

By Seth Fitzgerald
September 7, 2013 8:42AM

    Bookmark and Share
Motorola had agreed to offer the licensing at a lower rate, but then asked for 2.25 percent of the sale price of each Xbox and copy of Windows Microsoft sold. Microsoft refused to pay, and as a result Motorola sought an injunction in Germany against the company. To avoid distribution problems in Europe Microsoft moved a warehouse from Germany to the Netherlands.
 



A federal jury has ruled in Microsoft's favor in a patent case against Motorola, which had been brought on by Motorola's decision to go against an agreement to license essential patents at a reasonable rate. The ruling has resulted in Microsoft receiving $14 million, however, that is only half of what the company was asking for in court.

The jury that made this decision was involved in the second of two rounds in U.S. District Court in Seattle between Microsoft and Motorola over the patents. In the first round a judge decided on reasonable royalty rates for Microsoft to pay Motorola, amounting to an estimated $1.8 million annually. Before the trial, Motorola, owned by Google, had sought rates that Microsoft estimated would have cost it $4 billion a year.

"This is a landmark win for all who want products that are affordable and work well together," said David Howard, Microsoft deputy general counsel, in a statement after the jury's decision. "The jury's verdict is the latest in a growing list of decisions by regulators and courts telling Google to stop abusing patents."

The Patents

Microsoft had argued the patents in question were "standard-essential," meaning that the licensed technology was commonplace and necessary and not "unique" to a device from one specific company. Although the patents are valid, companies are required to offer licensing at lower rates.

Motorola had agreed to offer the licensing at a lower rate, but then asked for 2.25 percent of the sale price of each Xbox and copy of Windows Microsoft sold. Microsoft refused to pay, and as a result Motorola sought an injunction in Germany against the company. To avoid distribution problems in Europe Microsoft moved a warehouse from Germany to the Netherlands, which it said cost it $23 million to accomplish.

Relocating the warehouse constituted $11 million of the Jury-awarded settlement, with the remaining $3 million attributed to Microsoft's legal fees related to fighting a ban on its products.

Abuse of Patents

This is not the only standard-essential patent case to make headlines recently. Samsung lost a back-and-forth battle with the U.S. International Trade Commission last month after the panel ruled that Samsung had infringed on Apple patents. However, a ban on Samsung products as a result of the ruling will not go into effect until after a 60-day presidential review period expires.

Apple and Samsung have been involved in a number of patent battles in venues worldwide over the last several years, with one side or the other occasionally gaining advantage.

The real issue in most of these cases, whether they involve Microsoft, Motorola, Samsung, Apple or another company, is standard-essential patents. There are few that argue with the idea that patents are great at protecting unique and innovative ideas, but standard patents have recently come under fire.

Most people that criticize these patents bring up the valid point that just because someone was first to do something does not mean that other companies should be prevented from doing it. For example, if someone patented the use of a physical home button on a smartphone, should all other companies be prevented from using a home button without paying a fee? With the U.S. still handing out patents for ideas like this, more and more court cases continue to appear.
 

Tell Us What You Think
Comment:

Name:



Salesforce.com is the market and technology leader in Software-as-a-Service. Its award-winning CRM solution helps 82,400 customers worldwide manage and share business information over the Internet. Experience CRM success. Click here for a FREE 30-day trial.


 Computing
1.   Microsoft Revamps Office 365 Plans
2.   New OpenStack Release Available
3.   Windows 7 Ends Mainstream Support
4.   Another IE-Focused Patch Tuesday
5.   EMC Moves Toward Hybrid Cloud


advertisement
Review: Microsoft's Surface Pro 3
Is it a tablet and laptop replacement?
Average Rating:
New OpenStack Release Available
Red Hat touts VMware integration.
Average Rating:
Windows 7 Ends Mainstream Support
But extended support still available.
Average Rating:
Product Information and Resources for Technology You Can Use To Boost Your Business

Network Security Spotlight
Another Month, Another IE-Focused Patch Tuesday
Microsoft rolled out 59 vulnerabilities for Internet Explorer in June. But the IE-patching party is not over yet. Redmond published six new security bulletins on Tuesday; two, critical; three, important.
 
Russian Arrested in Hacking Case Filed in Seattle
The U.S. Secret Service has arrested a Russian man who is accused of hacking store computers to steal thousands of credit card numbers, charging him with bank fraud, identity theft and more.
 
More Than Half of Networks Not Ready for Internet of Things
Most enterprises are prepared for the IoT and see its business potential. But the reality is that there may not be enough network capacity to handle the increased demand in connected devices.
 

Enterprise Hardware Spotlight
Another Day, Another Internet of Things Consortium Is Born
In the emerging Internet of Things, zillions of devices will be talking to each other. Samsung, Intel and Dell just formed a consortium to ensure each thing can understand what others are saying.
 
Gartner Sales Study Sees Tablets Up, PCs Down but Recovering
Are PCs on the comeback trail? That depends on how you define "comeback." While tablet sales remain strong, Gartner's latest study found PC shipments aren't dropping as fast as they did last year.
 
Review: Warming Up to Tablets with Keyboard Covers
If you've ever thought tablets with keyboard covers were just a poor excuse for a laptop, think again. Nokia's Lumia 2520 comes with an optional keyboard cover that just may change your mind.
 

Navigation
NewsFactor Network
Home/Top News | Enterprise I.T. | Cloud Computing | Applications | Hardware | Mobile Tech | Big Data | Communications
World Wide Web | Network Security | Data Storage | Small Business | Microsoft/Windows | Apple/Mac | Linux/Open Source | Personal Tech
Press Releases
NewsFactor Network Enterprise I.T. Sites
NewsFactor Technology News | Enterprise Security Today | CRM Daily

NewsFactor Business and Innovation Sites
Sci-Tech Today | NewsFactor Business Report

NewsFactor Services
FreeNewsFeed | Free Newsletters | XML/RSS Feed

About NewsFactor Network | How To Contact Us | Article Reprints | Careers @ NewsFactor | Services for PR Pros | Top Tech Wire | How To Advertise

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
© Copyright 2000-2014 NewsFactor Network. All rights reserved. Article rating technology by Blogowogo. Member of Accuserve Ad Network.