News & Information for Technology Purchasers NewsFactor Sites:     Enterprise Security Today     CRM Daily     Business Report     Sci-Tech Today  
This ad will display for the next 20 seconds. Please click for more information, or scroll down to pass the ad, or Close Ad.
Home Enterprise I.T. Cloud Computing Applications Hardware More Topics...
APC Free White Paper
Optimize your network investment &
Enter to win a Samsung Galaxy Note
Linux/Open Source
24/7/365 Network Uptime
Average Rating:
Rate this article:  
Android Fragmentation vs Control: Is It Too Open?
Android Fragmentation vs Control: Is It Too Open?

By Barry Levine
April 7, 2011 10:58AM

    Bookmark and Share
Google is trying to balance market fragmentation for Android devices versus control. While a study found that 55 percent of Android developers find compatibility a problem, Google's Andy Rubin insists there are "basic compatibility requirements." And Rubin added that releasing Android 3.0 only to some manufacturers is just a "temporary delay."

One of Android's biggest advantages is that it is open, while one of its biggest disadvantages is -- it's open. Google is stepping up its effort to address the risk of fragmentation, while countering concern that it is beginning to exert too much control.

On Wednesday, Google Vice President of Engineering Andy Rubin posted on the company's Android Developers blog about this issue. "We don't believe in a 'one size fits all' solution," he wrote, adding that the platform has "spurred the development of hundreds of different devices -- many of which were not originally contemplated when the platform was first created."

'Basic Compatibility Requirements'

He added that "there are not, and never have been, any efforts to standardize the platform on any single chipset architecture."

Recently, some industry observers have questioned whether market fragmentation is taking place, and others have suggested that Google was beginning to exert more control in order to avoid fragmentation. A recent study from Robert W. Baird & Co., for instance, contended that 55 percent of Android developers find compatibility to be a problem.

Last month, Google said it was holding back its tablet-optimized Android 3.0 Honeycomb platform from smaller phone manufacturers because the OS had to be further refined to be released as open format. But it was being released to larger companies, such as Motorola and HTC, which led to complaints about Google's control and preferential treatment.

Rubin's blog post attempts to define the company's position. "This temporary delay," he said, "does not represent a change in strategy." While device makers are free to modify Android to customize any range of features for their devices, he said, the company does require conformity to "basic compatibility requirements" in a device that is marketed as Android-compatible or includes Google applications.

Frustration for Google and Licensees

"After all," he wrote, "it would not be realistic to expect Google applications -- or any applications for that matter -- to operate flawlessly across incompatible devices."

Rubin referenced a posting last May by the company's open-source program manager Dan Morrill, on the same blog. In it, Morrill said "fragmentation" means too many different things, including optional APIs that cause inconsistent platform implementation, or different user interface skins.

Morrill said Google's definition of Android compatibility is that the device can "properly run apps written with the Android SDK." Compatibility, he said, can be affected by bugs, missing hardware components, or non-standard APIs. He added that, since manufacturers are motivated to have Android Market apps run on their devices, they are "generally pretty motivated to ship compatible devices."

Ross Rubin, director of industry analysis for consumer technology at NPD Group, said platform control is a continuum, and Google is trying to manage both ends. He described Apple's tight platform control as one end, while completely open-source platforms are the other. Google, he said, "wants to compete with Apple" and other tightly controlled platforms, and has been "frustrated" when licensees, for instance, ship with an older Android.

But, he noted, licensees can also be frustrated when Google works more closely on the development and release of Android devices with some companies than with others.

Tell Us What You Think


Games Jandolfini:

Posted: 2011-04-10 @ 1:22pm PT
All these Rubins are making me hungry. And yeah, Android is half baked and Google has a poor strategy. I wonder why people think Google would be any good at developing an operating system? Because they made some web apps? Most of their web apps are in beta mode for years. Heck, on YouTube (owned by Google) the threaded comments are in "beta" (meaning that, you, the customer, are testing the product).

Hmmm... I work in software, and we typically recruit beta testers, give them the software and device for free, and even provide incentives to test the software. The notion of releasing a web app that customers are beta testing is not great. But doing this with a mobile operating system and having people pay for devices and data plans? That's EVIL. Google does no evil? Come on, they're straight out Robber Barons from Robber Baron U.

APC has an established a reputation for solid products that virtually pay for themselves upon installation. Who has time to spend worrying about system downtime? APC makes it easy for you to focus on business growth instead of business downtime with reliable data center systems and IT solutions. Learn more here.

 Linux/Open Source
1.   Red Hat Unveils OpenShift Marketplace
2.   IBM Mainframes Celebrate 50 Years
3.   Eich Resignation Brings Controversy
4.   Teradata Intros QueryGrid Analytics
5.   Mozilla CEO Resigns Amid Furor

Tech 101: What Is Open Source?
Foundation of countless applications.
Average Rating:
IBM Mainframes Celebrate 50 Years
Unveils new cloud services for business.
Average Rating:
Eich Resignation Brings Controversy
Political correctness in Silicon Valley.
Average Rating:
Product Information and Resources for Technology You Can Use To Boost Your Business

Network Security Spotlight
Tips To Defeat the Heartbleed Bug
Heartbleed headlines continue as IT admins scramble for answers no one has. Early reports of stolen personal data, including 900 social insurance numbers in Canada, are starting to trickle in.
NSC Backs Disclosing Software Vulnerabilities
Disclosing vulnerabilities in commercial and open source software is in the national interest and shouldn't be withheld unless there is a clear need, says the National Security Council.
Heartbleed Flaw Affects Hardware, Too
It appears the Heartbleed security bug affects not just Web sites, but also the networking equipment that connects businesses and homes to the Net, including Cisco and Juniper's equipment.

Enterprise Hardware Spotlight
Vaio Fit 11A Battery Danger Forces Recall by Sony
Using a Sony Vaio Fit 11A laptop? It's time to send it back to Sony. In fact, Sony is encouraging people to stop using the laptop after several reports of its Panasonic battery overheating.
Continued Drop in Global PC Shipments Slows
Worldwide shipments of PCs fell during the first three months of the year, but the global slump in PC demand may be easing, with a considerable slowdown from last year's drops.
Google Glass Finds a Home in Medical Education, Practice
Google Glass may find its first markets in verticals in which hands-free access to data is a boon. Medicine is among the most prominent of those, as seen in a number of Glass experiments under way.

Mobile Technology Spotlight
Is Amazon Launching a 3D Smartphone?
Once known for selling books on an e-commerce platform, Amazon is now a bona fide hardware maker -- and it's reportedly rolling out an innovative smartphone with a 3D screen.
Review: S5 Features Useful, Less About Gimmicks
There's a lot to like about Samsung's new Galaxy S5 smartphone -- among them, its relative lack of features. Samsung chose to focus on features people might actually want, not gimmicks.
Analyst: Samsung Galaxy S5 Won't Sway iPhone Lovers
The Samsung Galaxy S5 hits store shelves on Friday and the reviews are starting to pour in. The question is: Can the latest in the Galaxy line grab more market share from Appleā€™s iPhone?

NewsFactor Network
Home/Top News | Enterprise I.T. | Cloud Computing | Applications | Hardware | Mobile Tech | Big Data | Communications
World Wide Web | Network Security | Data Storage | Small Business | Microsoft/Windows | Apple/Mac | Linux/Open Source | Personal Tech
Press Releases
NewsFactor Network Enterprise I.T. Sites
NewsFactor Technology News | Enterprise Security Today | CRM Daily

NewsFactor Business and Innovation Sites
Sci-Tech Today | NewsFactor Business Report

NewsFactor Services
FreeNewsFeed | Free Newsletters | XML/RSS Feed

About NewsFactor Network | How To Contact Us | Article Reprints | Careers @ NewsFactor | Services for PR Pros | Top Tech Wire | How To Advertise

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
© Copyright 2000-2014 NewsFactor Network. All rights reserved. Article rating technology by Blogowogo. Member of Accuserve Ad Network.